| Platinum | Cassy's Cakes |
| Gold | Life's a Batch Baking Co |
| Silver | Bread Pete |
| Bronze | Ladycakes |
| Top Pick | Amore Italian Market and Bakery |
| Top Pick | Bam German Bakery and More |
| Top Pick | Mattie's Artisinal Bakery |
| Top Pick | Paradise Deli & Grill |
| Top Pick | Pies and Things |
| Top Pick | Sweet Real |