| Platinum | Mellow Mushroom |
| Gold | The Goombah Pizzaiolo |
| Silver | Leone's |
| Silver | Luciano's Pizza |
| Bronze | Nice Guys Pizza |
| Top Pick | Chicago Pizza |
| Top Pick | Downtown House of Pizza |
| Top Pick | Lelulo's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Maria's Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral |