| Platinum | Cassy's Cakes |
| Platinum | Life's a Batch Baking Co |
| Gold | Paradise Deli & Grill |
| Silver | Papa D's Cheesecake |
| Bronze | Ladycakes |
| Top Pick | Cape Creamery |
| Top Pick | Jiggly Tasty Japanese Cheese Cake |
| Top Pick | Umami Twist |
| Top Pick | Yonutz |
| Top Pick | Zirilli's Chilly Treats |