| Platinum | Stella Marie's Italian Market & Deli |
| Gold | Ristorante Fabio Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Two Meatballs in The Kitchen - Cape Coral |
| Bronze | Gusto Cucina Italiana |
| Top Pick | Amore Italian Market and Bakery |
| Top Pick | Buon Appetito Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Ceno Grille |
| Top Pick | Maria's Pizzeria & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Papa Joe's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Sicily Trattoria |